|Starting location:||The Office|
|First appearance:||Night 1|
Lucy Smith worked for the SSA and (regrettably) agreed with Jack Fischer's idea of returning to Treasure Island. However, Gary Howell extremely disagreed, to the point of leaving her alone on the island on purpose. She is the daughter of Jake Smith and found out on Night 3.
Lucy was killed by Undying on Night 5.
|Suits||Donald Duck's Body • Daisy Duck's body • Golden Mickey • Happy • José "Zé" Carioca • Ortensia • The Snake • The Visage • Vanellope Von Schweetz• Criminal The Wolf • Normal Mickey Suit • Minnie Mouse • Photo Negative Disembodied • Nightmare Suicide Mouse • The Mouse • The Beak • Old Mickey • Terror Mickey • The Rat • Pete • Olaf • Fleshpound • Happy Mouse • Decimated Mickey • The Conjoined|
|Humanoids||The Shade • TS|
|Humans||Gary Howell • Jack Fischer • Lucy Smith|
|Melted||Melted Mickey • Melted Donald • Melted Impure Mouse • Melted Suicide Mouse|
|Abandoned||Abandoned Suicide Mouse • Abandoned Photo Negative Minnie • Abandoned Photo Negative Mickey|
|Adventure||Adventure Acephalous • Adventure Disembodied|